Decoding Luxury Hotels

/

Hi there,

Just like an event can be good, great, excellent, or exceptional, the same is true for hotels and the experience they provide for travelers and groups visiting them. This week we’re diving deep into the world of luxury hospitality…exploring what truly sets apart the tiers of luxury hotels and why those famous star ratings might not tell the whole story. 

The Deceptive Nature of Star Ratings

Let’s face it - star ratings can be misleading. A five-star hotel in a secondary market might barely qualify as a four-star property in Paris or New York. Moreover, rating systems vary by country and certifying body. Some properties self-rate, while others undergo rigorous third-party evaluations. The key? Look beyond the stars.

The Good: Foundation of Luxury

Good luxury hotels, like good events deliver on expectations and nail the basics such as:

  • Immaculate cleanliness that extends beyond guest rooms to every corner

  • Professional staff who are well-groomed and courteous

  • Quality bedding with high thread-count linens

  • Reliable room service with decent presentation

  • Functioning amenities and basic concierge services

However, they often miss subtle details that keeps them from reaching higher levels of excellence. You might notice slight inconsistencies in service, generic toiletries, or standard restaurant offerings. These hotels are comfortable but don't create memorable moments and the same is true for basic well-done events. They might achieve the expectations, but they’re not going to be the event that creates catharsis and metamorphosis in an attendee or drives them to share about this event for years to come.

Hotels in this category include: Most Westin properties, Renaissance Hotels, Sofitel properties in secondary markets, Certain Kimpton Hotels, InterContinental Hotels in smaller markets

  • Standout Example: The Westin Palace Madrid - reliable luxury with good service, though not quite reaching the heights of Spain's most exclusive properties

Good Luxury Hotels Are Perfect For:

  • Business travel where comfort and reliability matter more than exceptional experiences

  • Large corporate conferences where consistent service matters more than customization

  • Short city breaks where the hotel serves primarily as a comfortable base

  • Events with strict budgets that still require an upscale venue

  • Training sessions where the focus is on content not experience

  • Industry conventions where adequate space matters more than luxury touches

The Great: Elevation Through Detail and Personalization 

Great luxury hotels, like great events, go the extra mile and deliver qualities like:

  • Anticipatory service that addresses needs before they're voiced

  • Personalized touches like welcome amenities based on guest preferences

  • Curated partnerships with local artisans and experiences

  • Signature scents and custom-branded luxury toiletries

  • Staff who remember returning guests and their preferences

  • Sophisticated F&B programs with talented culinary teams

These properties understand luxury is in the details, but might still struggle with consistency across all touch points.  Think: Most Four Seasons in secondary markets, Park Hyatt properties in Asia, Waldorf Astoria properties in the Americas, Rosewood properties in secondary markets, Many Edition Hotels

Standout Example: The Shangri-La Singapore - consistently excellent service with great attention to detail, while maintaining approachability

Great Luxury Hotels are best for:

  • Intimate corporate retreats requiring personalized attention

  • Smaller events/weddings (50-150 guests) seeking sophistication without extravagance

  • Family celebrations where attention to detail enhances the experience

  • Incentive travel programs for mid-sized groups

  • Product launches requiring elegant settings but not ultra-luxury

  • Multi-day conferences needing varied dining and entertainment options

The Excellent: Mastery of Experience

Excellent luxury hotels transcend traditional hospitality and just like great events, you know one when you experience it due to qualities like:

  • Flawless service choreography where every department works in perfect harmony

  • Innovative technology that enhances rather than complicates the stay

  • Exceptional concierge teams with impossible-to-get reservations at their fingertips

  • Unique programming that creates Instagram-worthy moments

  • Sublime dining experiences (Michelin star) that draw locals and travelers alike

  • Thoughtful design that tells a cohesive story throughout the property

The excellent category is where true luxury begins to shine. Think: Most Aman Resorts, Peninsula Hong Kong, Mandarin Oriental Bangkok, Ritz Carlton Paris, Four Seasons Paris, The Connaught London

Standout Example: The Peninsula Beverly Hills - masterful service execution with innovative programming and exceptional attention to detail

Excellent hotels are ideal for events like:

  • High-profile corporate board meetings

  • Luxury brand showcases and fashion events

  • Celebrity or VIP hosting

  • Larger weddings (150-300 guests) demanding seamless execution

  • International diplomatic gatherings

  • Premium incentive travel programs

The Exceptional: Beyond Hospitality to Truly Transformative

Exceptional luxury hotels exist in a realm of their own and are the true 1% of hospitality. Like life-changing events, one is lucky to have an opportunity to experience one, and it will often leave an impression that goes beyond memorable to transformative and inspirational:

  • Transformative experiences that change how guests view hospitality

  • Staff who operate like luxury brand ambassadors rather than traditional hotel employees

  • Partnerships with ultra-luxury brands that feel organic rather than commercial

  • Architecture, art collections and interior design that become destinations themselves

  • Culinary programs helmed by renowned chefs pushing creative boundaries and even include gourmet offerings for pets and children

  • Services that seem magical in their execution and timing

  • Cultural programming that connects guests with exclusive local experiences

These properties don't just exceed expectations—they redefine them. Think: Aman Tokyo, Four Seasons Florence, Laucala Private Island, Fiji, Royal Mansour Marrakech, Burj Al Arab Dubai, Raffles Singapore

Standout Example: Cheval Blanc Randheli Maldives - redefining luxury through unprecedented attention to detail, exceptional design, and transformative experiences

One might seek out a truly exceptional hotel for:

  • Royal and diplomatic state visits

  • Ultra-luxury brand global launches

  • Celebrity weddings requiring absolute privacy and security

  • International summit meetings

  • Exclusive gatherings of global leaders

  • Once-in-a-lifetime celebration events

  • Ultra-high-net-worth individual family gatherings and celebrations

  • Events requiring helicopter access or extreme security measures

The key is matching the hotel tier to both your purpose and your audience's expectations. Sometimes, an exceptional hotel might actually be too formal for a casual corporate retreat, while a great hotel might provide the perfect balance of luxury and approachability for your internal event while sending the right level of optics on corporate governance.

How to Identify True Luxury

Event planners: when looking for the right level of luxury, go beyond the obvious indicators of reputation and price point, and in an RFP, look for:

  1. Staff tenure and training programs

  2. The sophistication of their standard operating procedures

  3. How they handle special requests and customization

  4. The quality and exclusivity of their partnerships

  5. Their approach to sustainability and social responsibility

  6. The depth and breadth of their concierge services

  7. Their ability to create authentic local connections

  8. Responsiveness and communication

Event Planning at Luxury Properties: When Things Go Wrong

As an event planner, even the most exceptional properties can have off days. Here's how to handle suboptimal experiences:

Prevention:

  • Document everything in writing, including verbal agreements

  • Have detailed BEOs (Banquet Event Orders) signed off by all parties

  • Conduct thorough site inspections, including back-of-house areas and advance VIP rooms looking in all drawers, making sure all outlets work, etc.

  • Meet key team members who will execute your event and get their direct mobile number

  • Request contingency plans for weather, staffing, and other variables

When Issues Arise:

  1. Document Everything: Take photos, save emails, and keep detailed notes

  2. Maintain Professionalism: Even in frustrating moments, keeping calm helps resolve issues faster

  3. Escalate Appropriately: Know the chain of command and when to move up it

  4. Focus on Solutions: Present concrete ways to address problems rather than just highlighting issues

  5. Leverage Relationships: Your rapport with hotel management can often expedite solutions

After the Event:

  • Schedule a detailed debrief with the hotel team

  • Request specific compensation or future considerations if warranted

  • Document lessons learned for future events

  • Maintain professional relationships despite challenges

  • Consider whether the issues reflect a one-time situation or systemic problems

True luxury isn't about marble lobbies or designer uniforms—it's about creating moments that transform ordinary stays into extraordinary memories. The best properties understand that luxury is both an art and a science, requiring constant innovation while never losing sight of timeless hospitality principles.

What I’m Loving this week:  For all my favorite vendors, partners and products, visit: https://www.giannagaudini.com/gianna-recommends

Because it’s Valentine’s Day month…Read On All My Single Guys and Gals!

The Bevy: I recently returned from a 50th birthday celebration at The Edition Riviera Maya hosted by the founder of The Bevy. The Riviera Maya was a gorgeous destination, just over a year old with stunning architecture, one of the most amazing suites I’ve ever stayed in, and luxurious beach and five star dining. More than the venue, I loved catching up with the host and learning more about her wildly successful (95% success rate) bespoke matchmaking company, The Bevy, which was just featured in Goop (and formerly in other small publications like Forbes, Vogue, The Wall Street Journal, etc). It’s no coincidence that The Bevy is busy…with COVID behind us, and people sick of swiping apps, I’ve been approached by at least a dozen highly eligible singles this past year asking me if I know of anyone exceptional to match them with. Rather than do the matchmaking myself, I now have a reliable partner to help. Email me if you’d like an intro and I’m happy to connect you directly so you can manifest your dream relationship because life’s too short to be lonely.

XX,

Gianna

P. S. Need to chat? Book a 1:1 using my link for Expert advice on intro: intro.co/GiannaGaudini